Dined on Monday, October 19.
My group of guys has been to Delmonico's three times now. The previous two were outstanding with great service and great food. This time was clearly a swing and a miss.
We had reservations for five folks and were 15 minutes early for our reservation. 50 minutes later I checked on our reservation and had to ask the manager for a comped round of drinks for which he did oblige.
Despite the reservation, we were seated in the "front room" which is the lesser of the two dining areas and has less excitement thean being near the kitchen.
Our server, Vincent, was trying but was obviously harried. It was a bad night and I am thiniking there was a big staffing problem. He barely had time to talk to us.
We like our wines and were amazed when neither a somellier nor an assistant sommelier was on duty that night. We were sent a waiter that had a decent knowledge of the selections.
When the steaks arrived, two of the five had to be sent back for being overcooked.
I know this sounds like a picky review but when you are dropping $50 a pop for the entree, you have high standards.
The manager did comp us a dessert sampler plate, which was a nice gesture. I was hoping for something a little more dramatic.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.